beyondcrumbcatching

Name:
Location: chicago, IL, United States

Thursday, August 28, 2008

The Audacity of Hype: Is Bonehead Chicago Ready for Real Change Yet?

To:  wendt4chicago@yahoogroups.com

The Audacity of Hype: Is Bonehead Chicago Ready for Real Change Yet?

"Community organizers in the Alinsky tradition elusively combine the skills of the private detective, huckster, friend, anthropologist, priest, and military strategist. Few people have the stuff to make a career out of it. For those who came of age in the 1960s and 1970s, however, the two year stint as community organizer was the social equivalent of military service or joining a cult.

"Much Alinsky-style community organizing depends on a core of beliefs and rituals: that organizers and leaders are of different metaphysical types; that small issues lead to big issues; that there are enemies and that victories build leadership and organization; that community organizations should provide services; and that politics and ideology are dead ends.

"By the 1980s, community organizers could be found almost anywhere. In Baltimore, the head of a municipal development agency responded to a question about community organizing by saying,'I'm sure we can offer that service.' In Chicago, a public relations staffer for an expanding medical center proudly identifed himself as a former community organizer, and deftly divided the community by finding those groups and leaders whose threshold of victory was accepotable to the powers-that- be."

So began a review of Sanford D. Horwitt, Let Them Call Me Rebel: Saul Alinsky his Life and Legacy, by Robert Giloth, one of the more profound thinkers in tne Alinskyite movement and a former City of Chicago planning official. It was printed in The Neighborhood Works, October-November 1990, organ of an Alinskyite think tank, the Center for Neighborhood Technology. Giloth eventually went on to say:

"Let Them Call Me Rebel also recognizesd a major problem with Alinsky's organizing. It was short-term and often failed to build a core of values, leadership, and organizational structure that could weather the years while nuturing local democracy... ."

Barack Obama, the one-time Alinskyite community organizer, had to function in a world of rich white men, said Rev. Wright in passing. Indeed he has functioned in a world rich white men, very well indeed, even appearing at an official rally to support Chicago's Olympic bid and proclaiming he would lead the opening procession as one of his final acts as president, in a stadium blocks from his home in Hyde Park.

That is, a Chicago Olympics shortchanged by the urban renewal priorities of rich white men, which either Barack knows about or does not know about. Does he have any idea, or concern, how the City of Chicago has been passing up the only practical 80,000+ seat stadium site in the city, because a stadium there would interfere with "future housing plans"?

What follows is yours truly's long-standing objections to housing and transportation policies in Chicago that recently became embroiled in the Chicago Olympic bid and more recently in presidential politics.

There is a 60 acre abandoned railroad yard on the southern edge of downtown Chicago, not used for rail service for 35 years. Even the Chicago Tribune editorialized on April 25, 1986 that it is the most attractive, accessible stadium site in the city. It is in the midst of downtown public transportation, parking, and expressways. Ratings from the 1980s by the City itself and the Metropolitan Planning Council describe it as a magnificent site, except that stadium use would interfere with future housing plans.

The City putzed around two decades ago with a proposed stadium on the near west side, a site nowhere as advantageous merely from practical stadium considerations. Opposing this led yours truly into investigating other sites and the urban renewal implications of Roosevelt and the river, and to publishing the results in 1989.

The idea was not merely the baseball/football stadiums proposed by the downtown interests for another location, with a roof sliding between the two, but a diesel commuter train route linking the southwest side and O'Hare via the IC Grant Park trackage. This and several other transit alternatives had been ruled out because of impacts on the "Dearborn Park development area.

Earlier this decade the City plowed over $600 million into a 61,000 seat football stadium in a cramped, much less accessible location on a now despoiled lakefront. Yours truly testified against it at Chicago Plan Commission hearings and had a letter opposing it in the Southwest News-Herald, December 11, 2000.

The Landmarks Preservation Council of Illinois made an elaborate proposal a retractable roof football stadium just north of the Sox stadium. A similar stadium in Milwaukee cost $400 million. Yours truly recalls the architect estimating the cost of a similar football stadium at $450 million at a public presentation. It could have gone as easily at Roosevelt and the river.

Which means the City now has to putz around with a stadium somewhere else, say, Washington Park, some seven miles from the downtown and nowhere close to rail transportation.

The now convicted Tony Rezko was about to make those housing plans for this site much less future three years ago, when he got caught in an affirmative action scandal at O'Hare Field and was disqualified from getting Tax Increment Financing for his development. Since then the site has been purchased by Eddie DeBartolo, according to a March 18, 2006 Tribune article. That seems to be the same Eddie DeBartolo who got caught in a Lousiana gambling scandal about a decade ago and had to testify in court about bribing the governor of the state, but who can presumably get a TIF in Chicago.

What is this, then, about "future housing plans" in a city certainly not squeamish about knocking down existing neighborhoods?

Urban renewal in Chicago is like the water of which the fish knows nothing until it is beached. To understand how well Barack has gotten along, and, indeed, how boneheaded Chicago is about the subject, one has to understand at least an outline of Chicago urban renewal history. The "future housing plans" have to be understood in the context of long-standing ambitions of the downtown powers-that- be.

First, see Arnold Hirsch, Making the Second Ghetto, or Urban Renewal 101, on how the University of Chicago and allied institutions cleaned out the south side a half century ago, displacing tens of thousands of poor blacks, and got both state and federal urban renewal laws passed. It has background on Ferdinand Kramer's Lake Meadows and Prairie Shores developments, whose significance will soon be apparent.

The basic strategy might be gleaned from the seven index entries under "Central Area Committee" in Cohen and Taylor, American Pharaoh. In short, the downtown Chicago Republican business moguls struck a deal with the original Mayor Daley to surround the downtown with upscale housing. This is to create a "pleasant atmosphere" around the downtown and enhance its real estate values.

Barack has been berated for his links to Bill Ayers, the one-time Weather Underground bomber. Far more significant, however, whether Barack has ever met him or not, is Tom Ayers, Bill's father, former chairman of the electric company and prime mover behind Dearborn Park, the housing development in another former railroad yard just south of the downtown, just east of this site. See Lois Wille, At Home in the Loop: How Clout and Community Built Chicago's Dearborn Park, or Urban Renewal 102.

Written like a puff piece, it nevertheless 1) spotlights Ayers' key role, 2) says in so many words, in several places, that Dearborn Park's purpose is to have white people around the Chicago downtown, and 3) that a stadium in the area is anathema, even if Papa Bear Halas wanted to put one there, notably Chapter 3, "Papa Bear Searches for a Den," even if this particular site is across Clark St. and a rail line considered a barrier to development, pp139, 193-194.

Wille not only says that one of Dearborn Park's apartment buildings was even cited for racial discrimination, but, several times, that its developer, Ferdinand Kramer, had preferred whites in his older developments, Prairie Shores and Lake Meadows, for decades. pp110-111, 8, 69, 82-84, 100, 134, 170.

Indeed, Dearborn Park itself was largely stimulated by all the Super Fly wannabes infesting the Loop in the early 1970s. Developer Arthur Rubloff is even quoted, Wille, p6, the problem is people's conception of the downtown, "B-L-A-C-K."

The historic attitude of the downtown powers toward poor blacks is well displayed in Ross Miller, Here's the Deal: The Buying and Selling of a Great American City, Urban Renewal 103, on the Block 37 fiasco up to the mid 1990s. The former Block 37 was torn down largely to get rid of attractions for poor blacks.

(It is now the site of an airport express subway station, running into enormous cost overruns. Yours truly's commuter train plan could have done the same thing and been implemented almost for free, except for subsequent developments making through-routing at Union Station nearly impossible and obstructing the Grant Park right of way.)

This is curious indeed, if highly explanatory of a larger purpose, considering that the same downtown interests behind Dearborn Park were also behind the recently defunct Leadership Council for Metropolitan Open Communities. In particular, Ayers himself, even having been cited by the first Mayor Daley for saving the city, Wille, p3. This is the open housing agency formed after the tumultuous Martin Luther King open housing marches in 1966.

Open housing is (or was) a key downtown strategy, judging by Anthony Downs, Opening Up the Suburbs, 1973. Downs' father James was a key architect of 1950's urban renewal programs and was on the board of Chicago 21/Dearborn Park.

See Julia Abrahmson, A Neighborhood Finds Itself, a principal Hirsch source, on what happened in Hyde Park a half-century ago, when the University of Chicago neighborhood faced its own horde of poor black migrants. Chapter 11 illustrates the genteel way to run them out, city inspectors. It also shows the residents considering housing discrimination one of the underlying problems of the time, as was a lack of public housing.

Or see the 1955 and 1958 Housing Action Reports of the Metropolitan Planning and Housing Council, headed then by none other than Ferdinand Kramer, proclaiming open housing a moral duty. In other words, it was not the poor blacks pushing open housing back then, but the people who wanted to move them.

So is the Chicago Housing Authority "Plan for Transformation, " which, by a Chicago Tribune article of February 16, 2006, has moved most CHA residents to the inner suburbs. One would never know from Wille's book that those "horrid" CHA projects were planned by the same circles as Dearborn Park, but we can gather from Hirsch that CHA was heavily in the relocation business a half-century ago.

The downtown housing and open housing ploys are quite consistent in moving poor blacks away from the downtown. Actually the duplicity of the urban renewers leaves the Alinskyites far behind. And if the CHA residents are largely "transformed" to the suburbs, who needs the open housing movement any more?

Why has this not drawn a jeremiad from Rev. Wright or attracted the moral fervor of Father Pfleger? Why strain against the 19th century traumas of slaves and Indians and let this more recent abuse pass, over barely the past half-century, urban renewal?

(LPCI was hardly about to buck the Dearborn Park crowd, however, two LPCI staffers, Bette Cerf Hill and Barbara Lynne, being ground floor Dearborn Park boosters, Wille, p109. LPCI also wussed out on preserving Maxwell St. for similar reasons, per Phil Ransom's movie, Cheat You Fair. Maxwell St., however, is among the lower rungs of the economic ladder desperately needed by poor blacks to create better options than Super Fly wannabe.)

Why has not Barack himself said anything? Lisa Rogak, ed., Barack Obama in His Own Words, cover blurb, The Candidate Speaks on Everything From Abortion to the Middle East, has nothing on urban renewal. Nor does The Audacity of Hope, nothing even on housing.

James Merriner quotes him as declining to assist an urban renewal project on grounds of displacing poor people, Chicago, June 2008.
http://www.chicagom ag.com/Chicago- Magazine/ June-2008/ Obamas-Chicago- Posse/The- Friends-of- O/ www.jamesmerriner. com

He can hardly say anything beyond that, however, without calling into question his own institutional mileau, one indeed of rich white men, in which he has functioned so well indeed.

The University of Chicago is where he is a law professor and his wife a six-figure executive. He represented the U of C's neighborhood, Hyde Park, in the Illinois Senate.

Barack and Michelle met while interning at the Chicago law firm of Sidley and Austin, according to The New Yorker, March 10, 2008, and, actually, to his own book, The Audacity of Hope. The firm was legal counsel for the Chicago 21/Dearborn Park project, as Wille discusses at some length. Indeed, Chapter 12, on the epic struggle between Dearborn Park and near-by CHA residents for control of the school, even says Sidley and Austin represented the Dearborn Park parents in court for free against CHA parents, p151. This was right about the time Barack and Michelle met there.

Curious, too, that Barack had an op-ed in the Chicago Sun-Times, August 18, 2004, during his U.S. Senatorial campaign, supporting BOTH O'Hare expansion and a new Peotone airport. Never mind severe economic and environmental objections or enhanced ground transportation.

Roughly the same downtown crowd, however, is also behind O'Hare expansion, if under different organizational auspices. That, judging by the two page ads taken out in mid-May 2001 in the Chicago Tribune, the Chicago Sun-Times, and Crain's Chicago Business. One does have to have some idea how all the banks and utilities were operating under different names then.

The effort is spearheaded by billionaire Lester Crown, who heads Material Services Corporation and is a major stockholder in General Dynamics, a major military contractor. He is also a major Barack campaign contributor. And, according to Wille, he was the major figure in discouraging his father, Henry, and Halas from going ahead with a stadium. pp27-29

Curious, too, that their 1973 Chicago 21 Plan explicitly calls for the conversion of Meigs Field to park space. An Olympic proposal with the stadium in the abandoned railroad yard would go well, however, with a restored Meigs Field.

Indeed, the Lockheed Electra turboprop could get in and out of Meigs, just like its stablemate, the Hercules military transport. It is almost as fast a jet in the air, but uses a fraction of the fuel, lands at two-thirds the speed, and makes incomparably less noise.

The significance of the stadium site is further explained in the letters below to the international and US Olympic committees on the Chicago proposal, also noting a 1968 Anthony Downs article in the Fall 1968 Daedulus which outlines an "integrated core" strategy by which downtown housing expands and pushes everything else out of the city. He also decried "enrichment" strategies for the ghetto, on grounds it would attract the wrong people into the city. He backed off somewhat from this position in his 1973 book, Opening Up the Suburbs.

Following them in Barack's op-ed supporting both airports and also material on his campaign contributions.

September 12, 2006

To: International Olympic Committee
Chateau de Vidy 1007
Lausanne Switzerland

United States Olympic Committee
1 Olympic Plaza
Colorado Springs, Colorado 80909

Dear Sirs/Madams:

Unless you make your own special effort to assess the site at Roosevelt Road and the river, easily the best stadium site in the city of Chicago, actually the only practical one, it will pass under your radar. Unless you open a public discussion of it you might easily miss the best site anywhere else as well. It is over sixty, unobstructed acres of abandoned railroad yard, unused for over three decades, for which recent development plans have recently collapsed amidst some scandal. Less than a mile walk from downtown public transportation and parking, it is also in the midst of near-by expressways. No less than the Chicago Tribune, April 25, 1986, called it the most attractive, most accessible stadium site in the city, which it definitely is. It has been highly rated by prominent civic bodies, even the City itself. Enclosed are ratings for stadium use from then, qualified upon infrastructure that has since largely been built. The site is easily viewed
from the recently reconstructed Roosevelt Road bridge, which itself creates a ready-made walkway to the fifteen or so vacant acres to the north, and which has a magnificent view of the downtown.

Immediately to their north is River City, an avant-garde but failed and somewhat droopy mid-rise housing complex which might finally find itself as an Olympic village. (And just beyond is the still vacant site of Grand Central Station, the architectural gem of Chicago train stations, which I would like to see reconstructed. )

A serious Olympic proposal would also reopen near-by Meigs Field. If there is some island of sanity in the airline industry, it might even be served by 2016 with the Lockheed Electra, the original airliner version of the veteran navy patrol plane, almost as fast as jets in the air but which can serve small airports with little noise and using much less fuel.

A serious proposal would also offer to install a promising monorail technology to connect the two and other points in the city. The current Olympic proposal by the City of Chicago is to build a temporary stadium in parking lots just south of the new $606 million but grossly mislocated and grossly inadequate football stadium on the lakefront. The site is considerably less accessible and more congested, in the midst of heavily used lakefront museums and exhibition halls. It has only one major road and one transit line near-by, and that a barrier to the west. About twice as far from the downtown as Roosevelt and the river, with precious new upscale downtown neighborhoods just across the multi-track electric commuter line, pedestrian access is poor, to say the least. The real reason for passing over the incomparably superior site is in those same ratings, that it has long been saved for downtown housing. This is also the real reason for closing Meigs, as
shown in the 1973 Chicago 21 Plan.

Questioning such long-standing ambitions is simply not done in local circles, even among the loyal, enervated opposition. See Cohen and Taylor, American Pharaoh, index entries under "Central Area Committee," as to how this town has been run for the past fifty years. The City originally proposed a stadium on the Sportsmans Park horsetrack site about three miles north of Midway Field and an Olympic village on the abandoned U. S. Steel site on the south lakefront. These sites are not far from the route of the long proposed Mid-City transit route, some 20 miles along Cicero and 75th, the former Crosstown Expressway route and lately proposed for a truck by-pass. It is only ten years until the 2016 Olympics, but it might be possible to install a heavy-duty monorail on that same route, one capable of hauling trucks as well as passenger vehicles. This particular if little known technology could allow mile-a-minute express runs as well, thus making possible a
scattered site Olympics with high-speed links among the three sites, no more than fifteen minutes from each other.

Unfortunately the City of Chicago stunted its own industrial development for decades, instead insulating the downtown from poor neighborhoods. Indeed, a fall 1968 Daedulus article by the long dreaded planner Anthony Downs decried "enrichment" strategies that would attract poor migrants and adovcated the "integrated core" strategy by which downtown housing would expand and eventually push everything else out of the city.

Unfortunately, too, there are precious few people in this precariously toddlin' town willing and able to discuss such things and they are convinced no one else cares. Too, Second City syndrome is still in full effect here; no one pays any attention unless you make a splash somewhere else. That an Olympic bid could advance this far with these issues unmentioned in public shows the paralysis of the civic culture.

It will take an out-of-town influence to get things off dead-center. Otherwise downtown housing could easily push out the Olympics too. The current situation is more fluid than usual because of the upcoming municipal election in February. While intervention in the election would be no proper role of yours, you still have a duty to secure the best possible site. Thus you have a vital, proper interest in land use and transportation policies, inevitable political implications notwithstanding. Thus you have a most proper interest, even a public responsibility, in opening a full discussion of these matters, election or not.

You do have to toot your own horn, don't you? Who else will? Is the Missouri mule ready for reform yet? Who knows, but the 2 x 4 will have to come from out of town.

William F. Wendt, Jr. -

March 6, 2007

International Olympic Committee United States Olympic Committee

Dear Sirs/Madams:

This letter is merely to criticize the current Chicago proposal for the 2016 Olympics in the light of long-standing housing and transportation scandals. Enclosed is a so far unanswered letter from last September offering a far superior alternative. Not enclosed is the supporting documentation, that future housing plans trumped its stadium use two decades ago. Let me know if you need it again.

Nothing has changed in that proposal, except the City approved a major development for the vacant acreage north of the site. Also, the City has no current plans for it, based on a City planner's presentation last month. Who knows when the "dirty graft" will hit the fan, because of land deals between the since indicted Tony Rezko, the site's last prospective developer, and Sen. Barack Obama.

The current proposal is for a temporary stadium in Washington Park, about seven miles south of downtown, and for a permanent Olympic Village of a thousand or more units on the near south lakefront. Obviously Washington Park does not have the benefit of extensive downtown transportation, handling about 500,000 people a day. It is a good half-mile from the nearest rail stations, together doing about 10,000 passengers a day, if that.

Transportation arrangements were not even mentioned at the 2016 committee presentation March 1, 2007 at the Chicago Architecture Foundation. Meanwhile the Chicago transit agencies proclaim this is the "year of decision," whether they get billions to repair the existing system. By their own statement in the Tribune last week, it will not happen next year because of the election.

Meanwhile, the O'Hare extension, barely two decades old, is plagued with slow zones for lack of track maintainence, also blamed for a derailment in the subway. There have been cosmetic station rehabs in recent years, on the other hand, getting into eight figures, at least.

The RTA solicited a dozen entrants in a technology contest a decade and a half ago but only mentioned two. One could do much more for much less than familiar technologies, but, at this late date, even I, its most diligent local advocate for almost two decades, would not propose it for more than auxiliary use in a major event less than a decade off.

The far larger scandal, however, is housing, the nanny state for upscale housing. This sleeptoddlin' town does not need another thousand or more luxury units on the lakefront. How much do you want to bet on the housing market a decade off, considering recent news items?

A 1980 transit planning document even said to concentrate all traffic on the existing elevated, rather than elevateds on both sides of Dearborn Park. Since the previous letter service has been disrupted there twice.

I am severely disappointed these issues were not raised in the recent city elections, but that merely reinforces my evaluation of the local civic culture. What is not a scandal here is the real scandal. Second City syndrome is still in full effect.

William F. Wendt, Jr.

PS Traffic on that stretch of elevated has been disrupted twice again since this letter was written.

Obama himself had this commentary in the August 18, 2004 Sun-Times:

Expanded O'Hare, or 3rd airport? Chicago area needs both // Expanded air capacity will benefit all Illinoisans through more jobs, economic growth and more flights.
============ ========= ========= ========= ========= ==
Chicago Sun-Times (IL)-August 18, 2004 Author: Barack Obama

In my eight years in the Illinois Senate, and in many years of community involvement before that, I have often found that opposing viewpoints could be reconciled through respectful negotiation and principled compromise. Usually, those on either side of an issue had legitimate interests at heart. What was necessary was finding a solution that satisfied both.

One of the seemingly intractable challenges facing Illinois policymakers is how to address the need for greater airport capacity in our state's northeastern region. Some advocate the expansion of O'Hare Airport, the world's busiest, which is suffering from delays that threaten its future as the economic engine of our region.

Others advocate the construction of a new airport near south suburban Peotone, which would reduce pressure on O'Hare while spreading the economic bounty more equitably across the region.

This challenge is often portrayed as an "either-or" proposition: We either expand O'Hare or build Peotone. I believe we should do both.

There is no denying the continuing importance of O'Hare to our regional economy. It is responsible for 450,000 jobs and $38 billion in economic activity. Those huge benefits are threatened by increasing delays and possible flight caps, which could drive air traffic to other airports in other locations. A modernized O'Hare would mean the creation of 195,000 more jobs and another $18 billion in annual economic activity. It would be a grave mistake for policymakers to fail to make the needed investments and allow O'Hare's central role in our regional economy to be diminished.

At the same time, there is a strong case for a third regional airport in the south suburbs -- a region that has struggled economically while other suburban areas have prospered. Employment and income in the south suburbs lags the rest of the Chicago area. The construction and operation of a new airport near Peotone would bring 1,000 construction jobs in the next two years and 15,000 permanent jobs by the first full year of the airport's operations, as well as billions of dollars in new economic activity, to residents and communities that sorely need it.

While the airlines and federal government would pay most of the cost of O'Hare expansion, a major objection to building Peotone has been the potential burden on state taxpayers. But U.S. Rep. Jesse Jackson Jr., a key leader in the Peotone effort, has assembled a group of private investors who are willing to risk their capital on the new airport's prospects. State government's role in the project would be limited to providing infrastructure improvements, such as roads, transit and sewers, which it routinely provides to other development projects around the state. The state also can continue to acquire the necessary land for the project, making sure to adequately compensate local landowners who live within the airport's footprint.

Jackson's proposal is a strong one in a time of expanding government deficits. And, by providing an alternative to federal funds being used in the airport's development, it would complement -- rather than compete with -- Midway and O'Hare. I am hopeful that the South Suburban Airport Commission and Will County officials can come together to work toward balanced economic growth and agree on a unified approach that will provide for economic benefits throughout the south suburbs.

The benefits of a south suburban airport would not be limited to the Chicago region. Many Downstate communities are hampered by their lack of air access to Chicago, since gates for such flights are extremely limited at O'Hare and Midway. An airport near Peotone would provide Downstate communities with enhanced air access to Chicago, as well as accommodating general aviation traffic that formerly utilized Meigs Field. In addition, as the world's first and only airport custom designed, built and priced to attract low-cost carriers, it will attract air service to the Chicago area by startup and discount airlines currently not operating out of Chicago's existing airports.

The bottom line is that expanded air capacity in the Chicago region will benefit all Illinoisans through more jobs, economic growth and more flights to and from Downstate. Achieving these goals need not be an either-or proposition. Through a willingness to compromise and work together in pursuit of our common interests, we can accommodate both an expanded O'Hare and a new third airport. The pressing need for good jobs and economic growth demands that we accept nothing less.

State Sen. Barack Obama is the Democratic candidate for the U.S. Senate from Illinois. Section: Editorials Page: 59

jack@areco.org, www.areco.org, supplies the following:

From the Chicago host list- Jim [James] Crown…Here’s some of my earlier research on the Crowns and the Obama campaign: ____________ _________ _______ Just after Obama spoke out against the impending Iraq war (October 26, 2002) at the Chicago anti-war rally– his campaign coffers were being generously filled by the renown Chicago “Crown Dynasty” family, as they are called. Per the Center for Responsive Politics site, the Crown family have owned and run General Dynamics, a major US defense contractor and comprise a healthy sector of its board. Holding titles such as Company President and Chairman are: Henry Crown, Lester Crown (also on the board of Israeli Aircraft industries), and James (Jim) Crown Total Crown funds taken in by the anti-war Obama over a two year election cycle prior to his Senate run add up to around $120,000. General Dynamics’ 2006 total revenues figures were listed at over $24 Billion. Forbes estimates the Crown family’s
worth at $3.6 Billion. Donations To Obama from the Crowns

Steven Crown—– $12,000 William Crown—– $12,000 Patricia Crown—–$12,000 Elizabeth Crown— $12,000 James Crown—- $14,000 Rebecca Crown—–$12,000 Renee Crown—– $14,000 Susan Crown—– $17,000 Paula Crown—– $13,500 ____________ _________ __

Crown contrib’s— $118,500 TOTAL
http://chicago. indymedia. org/newswire/ display/76429/ index.php
Also, for the 2008 election cycle they have already contributed an additional $61,000 to Senator Obama. http://www.opensecr ets.org/indivs/ search_hp. asp?txtName= Crown&NumOfThou= 0&txt2008= Y&submit= Go%21

Sunday, July 01, 2007

CHEAT YOU UNFAIR
Phil Ranstrom’s Cheat You Fair is 100 minutes of
superb material on Maxwell St., but it does not quite
cover the waterfront. I told him after the premier
showing (in early April) there is plenty material for
a sequel. There was little on Mexican vendors in the old
place, and the dirty pool on Maxwell St.’s undoing would have to
cover their efforts as well. That is,even if it is not the most
suitable material for cinema.
And if it is the best popular introduction to urban
renewal grand strategy, it also probes the limits of
cinematic art in dealing with it, like too many
talking heads. So let's try another medium.
The discussion after the first showing raised the
question of other threats are on the horizon and the
Olympics was the most immediate answer. The two are
curiously intertwined.
A group of Mexican vendors went to Springfield three
times in May 1994 to stop the UIC appropriation to buy
the old market area. I wound up tagging along. We were
told the matter had passed the Senate but not the
House. We made an appearance before the appropriations
committee, where it was transferred to higher
education. The higher education committee promised us
a hearing in Chicago, on the record, at then Rep.
Shirley Jones’ suggestion, who represented the area.
While waiting to be notified,however, we heard
the night before of a hearing in Springfield on the matter,
and we could not confirm,after hours, whether it was to take place.
The tape of the hearing records former Ald. Ted Mazola, the market’s
arch-enemy, saying vendors were being told the matter
was fait accompli, also representatives wondering if
everyone were present. The phony vendors’ group there
only discussed relocation of the market, not stopping
the appropriation altogether.
A lawyer filed a suit, but fizzled out altogether.
About a year later I came across the provision in the
Illinois constitution requiring reasonable notice of
legislative hearings. I filed my own lawsuit under it
and the right to petition for redress of grievances.
The state courts blew off the constitutional
questions. The federal courts took the matter as an
unauthorized appeal of a state court matter, never
mind that void decisions are a trial court matter and
the explicit requirements of Rooker-Feldman doctrine.
Never mind either, that nullification of the law is a
legislative act and a violation of sworn duty when
juries do it. How about judges nullifying the law? So
the old market is itself stolen goods.
The Washington Park stadium proposal skips over the
same abandoned railroad yard where the U of I should
have been located almost a half-century ago. By U of I
prof George Rosen’s own book, Decision Making,
Chicago-Style, published by the U of I press, the
urban renewal crowd had excellent reasons for putting
the campus in the south loop railroad yards, reasons
that look even better now with the subsequent influx
of educational institutions in the area. But there
were snags in obtaining the railroad land and the
downtown powers had long wanted to wipe out the
Harrison-Halsted neighborhood anyway.
Apparently there was no proposal to put a campus
merely on the riverfront Grand Central Station
property. There were major passenger operations in the
other stations, but the minor Soo Line trains at Grand
Central were shifted to Central Station in 1963 and
the Chesapeake & Ohio/Baltimore & Ohio trains shifted
to the Northwestern Station in 1969, when Grand
Central was closed. This required little more than
different instructions in the railroad towers to
reroute the trains.
The eighty-plus acres could have provided a
spectacular and magnificently accessible campus. Since
then their only development has been the bankrupt,
droopy River City. Although they would make a
magnificent stadium site too, evaluations by the City
and the Metropolitan Planning Council two decades ago
said that would interfere with future housing plans.
Preserving the lakefront and Soldier Field inspired a
lot of loud barking from behind the fence, but the
pixalated preservationists wussed out on this one too.
So the City and the Bears plowed over $600 million
into a cramped, poorly accessible Mistake-on-the Lake,
while passing over this site again and creating the
present problem.
Its most recent development proposal fell through
when the much berated Tony Rezko got caught in an
affirmative action scam. Olympic chairman Patrick Ryan
is a director of the Bears and is, to all outward
appearances, is still squeamish about knocking down a
neighborhood that does not exist. So risk the Olympic
bid on incomparably less accessible Washington Park.
See the easily available Cohen and Taylor, American
Pharaoh, index entries under “Central Area Committee,”
for an introduction to the grand strategy over the
past half-century of surrounding the downtown with
upscale housing. The more ambitious might dig up the
Anthony Downs article in the Fall 1968 Daedalus
academic journal, on this upscale housing expanding
and pushing everthing else out of the city. Maybe even
the Olympics too?
Downs is also the principal exponent of suburbanizing
the poor and of “triage” theories to destroy
neighborhoods. His father James founded the profession
of property management and played several roles in
locating the U of I campus.
To see this strategy in action, the less ambitious
can merely take the trolley rides in June from the
Printers’ Row book fair to 35th St. and listen to
guide spell out where all the condos and town houses
are going in.
Who knows, that old railroad yard just might be the
place for a new Maxwell St. neighborhood. That is, a
neighborhood, offering the steppingstones a mere
Sunday street market cannot, ironically where the U of
I should have been.