Name:
Location: chicago, IL, United States

Sunday, July 01, 2007

CHEAT YOU UNFAIR
Phil Ranstrom’s Cheat You Fair is 100 minutes of
superb material on Maxwell St., but it does not quite
cover the waterfront. I told him after the premier
showing (in early April) there is plenty material for
a sequel. There was little on Mexican vendors in the old
place, and the dirty pool on Maxwell St.’s undoing would have to
cover their efforts as well. That is,even if it is not the most
suitable material for cinema.
And if it is the best popular introduction to urban
renewal grand strategy, it also probes the limits of
cinematic art in dealing with it, like too many
talking heads. So let's try another medium.
The discussion after the first showing raised the
question of other threats are on the horizon and the
Olympics was the most immediate answer. The two are
curiously intertwined.
A group of Mexican vendors went to Springfield three
times in May 1994 to stop the UIC appropriation to buy
the old market area. I wound up tagging along. We were
told the matter had passed the Senate but not the
House. We made an appearance before the appropriations
committee, where it was transferred to higher
education. The higher education committee promised us
a hearing in Chicago, on the record, at then Rep.
Shirley Jones’ suggestion, who represented the area.
While waiting to be notified,however, we heard
the night before of a hearing in Springfield on the matter,
and we could not confirm,after hours, whether it was to take place.
The tape of the hearing records former Ald. Ted Mazola, the market’s
arch-enemy, saying vendors were being told the matter
was fait accompli, also representatives wondering if
everyone were present. The phony vendors’ group there
only discussed relocation of the market, not stopping
the appropriation altogether.
A lawyer filed a suit, but fizzled out altogether.
About a year later I came across the provision in the
Illinois constitution requiring reasonable notice of
legislative hearings. I filed my own lawsuit under it
and the right to petition for redress of grievances.
The state courts blew off the constitutional
questions. The federal courts took the matter as an
unauthorized appeal of a state court matter, never
mind that void decisions are a trial court matter and
the explicit requirements of Rooker-Feldman doctrine.
Never mind either, that nullification of the law is a
legislative act and a violation of sworn duty when
juries do it. How about judges nullifying the law? So
the old market is itself stolen goods.
The Washington Park stadium proposal skips over the
same abandoned railroad yard where the U of I should
have been located almost a half-century ago. By U of I
prof George Rosen’s own book, Decision Making,
Chicago-Style, published by the U of I press, the
urban renewal crowd had excellent reasons for putting
the campus in the south loop railroad yards, reasons
that look even better now with the subsequent influx
of educational institutions in the area. But there
were snags in obtaining the railroad land and the
downtown powers had long wanted to wipe out the
Harrison-Halsted neighborhood anyway.
Apparently there was no proposal to put a campus
merely on the riverfront Grand Central Station
property. There were major passenger operations in the
other stations, but the minor Soo Line trains at Grand
Central were shifted to Central Station in 1963 and
the Chesapeake & Ohio/Baltimore & Ohio trains shifted
to the Northwestern Station in 1969, when Grand
Central was closed. This required little more than
different instructions in the railroad towers to
reroute the trains.
The eighty-plus acres could have provided a
spectacular and magnificently accessible campus. Since
then their only development has been the bankrupt,
droopy River City. Although they would make a
magnificent stadium site too, evaluations by the City
and the Metropolitan Planning Council two decades ago
said that would interfere with future housing plans.
Preserving the lakefront and Soldier Field inspired a
lot of loud barking from behind the fence, but the
pixalated preservationists wussed out on this one too.
So the City and the Bears plowed over $600 million
into a cramped, poorly accessible Mistake-on-the Lake,
while passing over this site again and creating the
present problem.
Its most recent development proposal fell through
when the much berated Tony Rezko got caught in an
affirmative action scam. Olympic chairman Patrick Ryan
is a director of the Bears and is, to all outward
appearances, is still squeamish about knocking down a
neighborhood that does not exist. So risk the Olympic
bid on incomparably less accessible Washington Park.
See the easily available Cohen and Taylor, American
Pharaoh, index entries under “Central Area Committee,”
for an introduction to the grand strategy over the
past half-century of surrounding the downtown with
upscale housing. The more ambitious might dig up the
Anthony Downs article in the Fall 1968 Daedalus
academic journal, on this upscale housing expanding
and pushing everthing else out of the city. Maybe even
the Olympics too?
Downs is also the principal exponent of suburbanizing
the poor and of “triage” theories to destroy
neighborhoods. His father James founded the profession
of property management and played several roles in
locating the U of I campus.
To see this strategy in action, the less ambitious
can merely take the trolley rides in June from the
Printers’ Row book fair to 35th St. and listen to
guide spell out where all the condos and town houses
are going in.
Who knows, that old railroad yard just might be the
place for a new Maxwell St. neighborhood. That is, a
neighborhood, offering the steppingstones a mere
Sunday street market cannot, ironically where the U of
I should have been.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home